Coins: 12,918
Exchanges: 942
Market Cap: $2.263T 1.8%
24h Vol: $114.849B
Gas: 38 GWEI
Go Ad-free

Peter Todd: Bitcoin XT Helped People Learn About Bitcoin Governance

by Kyle Torpey

The implementation of BIP 101 into Bitcoin XT has been, perhaps, the most controversial move in the Bitcoin development community up to this point. Bitcoin XT’s acceptance of larger blocks has been embraced by some Bitcoin Core contributors, while others are wary of making a change that could alter the requirements for running a full node on the network. Bitcoin Core Contributor Peter Todd has been a vocal critic of BIP 101, but he has found a reason to be happy about the proposal’s inclusion in Mike Hearn’s Bitcoin XT.

The Community Should Control Protocol Changes

Peter Todd does not believe that a block size increase should be taken lightly, but he does see value in helping more people learn about Bitcoin governance through the battle between Bitcoin Core and Bitcoin XT. During the recent Bitcoin Pacifica 2015 Bitcoin Governance Panel, Todd expanded on the idea that changes to the protocol should come through community adoption rather than a cabal of core developers:

“I personally, I was extremely happy to go see Bitcoin XT, get developed and get pushed because from a governance point of view I think it really helped people understand how did the governance of bitcoin actually work to the extent that it was not under control for a small group of people. It’s rather convincing that a much broader community -- to go into offering something and if it turns out that the Bitcoin XT becomes more popular than Bitcoin Core, great. I would be very glad to see that recognition happen -- that it is not those group of people who control things, it’s rather community adoption. How we measure community adoption, how we get the process, that’s very tricky but I wouldn’t want to be working at the system where that wasn’t true.”

Bitcoin Core Developers Avoid Controversial Changes

There is a misconception of how the Bitcoin development process works in certain segments of the overall Bitcoin community. Some people believe that the Bitcoin Core developers have ultimate control over the protocol, but that is not true when you consider that a new development team can fork the code and create a completely different software client. The Bitcoin XT controversy has been a useful illustration of this point. As Todd noted during the recent panel discussion, the knowledge that the overall community also has a say in development matters has prevented Bitcoin Core developers from making controversial protocol changes in the past:

“I’m going to make the point though that as much as you have this notion of the Bitcoin Core devs call the shots, in practice I think they’re extremely concerned and they recognize and they think about this all the time, the issue, to the extent that they want to go push through a change that does not have wide consensus across the entire community. For the most part, they’ve always avoided that. I can’t think off the top of my head, any changes that we’ve made to bitcoin core where a significant chunk of the community really disagree with.”

It’s possible that having multiple software clients with different development teams could free developers up to implement more progressive changes that may not make their way into the current, somewhat-stagnant Bitcoin Core system.

Users Won’t Adopt Changes Against Their Will

One last note made by Todd during the panel discussion had to do with what actually happens when a controversial change is brought to the core developers. Sure, the developers could implement the change, but the reality is users don’t have to upgrade to the new version of Bitcoin Core against their will:

“Always what happens is, if you run into a situation like that, for the most part, you do nothing and to the extent I would say, it’s not a case where it’s a centralized environment. It’s a case where, sure, a small group of people have a little bit and some sort of Github that lets them push the change on some location but the concept of what Bitcoin is, is not under the control of any one group of people. It may look that way, but I think we would point out very quickly, had those people tried to make a change against the will of others, nothing would have happened.”

Although “doing nothing” has been the solution for controversial protocol changes in the past, that philosophy does not work for something as vital as scaling the blockchain to accommodate more users and transactions. It appears that some progress has been made in the block size limit debate over the past few months, but there is still work to be done when it comes to finding the proper governance model for Bitcoin.

Tell us how much you like this article!
Kyle Torpey
Kyle Torpey

Kyle is a freelance writer who has been interested in bitcoin since 2011. His work has been featured on Business Insider, VICE Motherboard, Let's Talk Bitcoin, RT's Keiser Report, and many other media outlets. Follow the author on Twitter @kyletorpey

More Articles

coingecko
Continue in app
Track prices in real-time
Open App
Select Currency
Suggested Currencies
USD
US Dollar
IDR
Indonesian Rupiah
TWD
New Taiwan Dollar
EUR
Euro
KRW
South Korean Won
JPY
Japanese Yen
RUB
Russian Ruble
CNY
Chinese Yuan
Fiat Currencies
AED
United Arab Emirates Dirham
ARS
Argentine Peso
AUD
Australian Dollar
BDT
Bangladeshi Taka
BHD
Bahraini Dinar
BMD
Bermudian Dollar
BRL
Brazil Real
CAD
Canadian Dollar
CHF
Swiss Franc
CLP
Chilean Peso
CZK
Czech Koruna
DKK
Danish Krone
GBP
British Pound Sterling
GEL
Georgian Lari
HKD
Hong Kong Dollar
HUF
Hungarian Forint
ILS
Israeli New Shekel
INR
Indian Rupee
KWD
Kuwaiti Dinar
LKR
Sri Lankan Rupee
MMK
Burmese Kyat
MXN
Mexican Peso
MYR
Malaysian Ringgit
NGN
Nigerian Naira
NOK
Norwegian Krone
NZD
New Zealand Dollar
PHP
Philippine Peso
PKR
Pakistani Rupee
PLN
Polish Zloty
SAR
Saudi Riyal
SEK
Swedish Krona
SGD
Singapore Dollar
THB
Thai Baht
TRY
Turkish Lira
UAH
Ukrainian hryvnia
VEF
Venezuelan bolívar fuerte
VND
Vietnamese đồng
ZAR
South African Rand
XDR
IMF Special Drawing Rights
Cryptocurrencies
BTC
Bitcoin
ETH
Ether
LTC
Litecoin
BCH
Bitcoin Cash
BNB
Binance Coin
EOS
EOS
XRP
XRP
XLM
Lumens
LINK
Chainlink
DOT
Polkadot
YFI
Yearn.finance
Bitcoin Units
BITS
Bits
SATS
Satoshi
Commodities
XAG
Silver - Troy Ounce
XAU
Gold - Troy Ounce
Select Language
Popular Languages
EN
English
RU
Русский
DE
Deutsch
PL
język polski
ES
Español
VI
Tiếng việt
FR
Français
PT
Português
All Languages
AR
العربية
BG
български
CS
čeština
DA
dansk
EL
Ελληνικά
FI
suomen kieli
HE
עִבְרִית
HI
हिंदी
HR
hrvatski
HU
Magyar nyelv
ID
Bahasa Indonesia
IT
Italiano
JA
日本語
KO
한국어
LT
lietuvių kalba
NL
Nederlands
NO
norsk
RO
Limba română
SK
slovenský jazyk
SL
slovenski jezik
SV
Svenska
TH
ภาษาไทย
TR
Türkçe
UK
украї́нська мо́ва
ZH
简体中文
ZH-TW
繁體中文
Login to track your favorite coin easily 🚀
By continuing, you agree to CoinGecko Terms of Service and acknowledge you’ve read our Privacy Policy
or
Forgot your password?
Didn't receive confirmation instructions?
Resend confirmation instructions
IT'S FREE! Track your favorite coin easily with CoinGecko 🚀
By continuing, you agree to CoinGecko Terms of Service and acknowledge you’ve read our Privacy Policy
or
Password must contain at least 8 characters including 1 uppercase letter, 1 lowercase letter, 1 number, and 1 special character
Didn't receive confirmation instructions?
Resend confirmation instructions
Forgot your password?
You will receive an email with instructions on how to reset your password in a few minutes.
Resend confirmation instructions
You will receive an email with instructions for how to confirm your email address in a few minutes.
Get the CoinGecko app.
Scan this QR code to download the app now App QR Code Or check it out in the app stores