Coins: 14,807
Exchanges: 1,130
Market Cap: $2.239T 0.5%
24h Vol: $92.821B
Gas: 12.137075784 GWEI
Go Ad-free
Coverage
TABLE OF CONTENTS

Bitcoin vs Western Union: How Low Fees Are Disrupting the Remittance Industry

Clement Chan -

Sending money internationally, or remittance, costs money. According to The World Bank, this costs an average of 7.99% of the amount sent.

In 2014, these cross-border transactions are expected to reach $582 billion, and up to $608 billion in 2015. It goes without saying that reducing the transaction costs by a few percentage points can save migrants billions of dollars collectively.

Migrant workers and immigrants typically send money back to their families in their home country, but using traditional payment methods like Western Union or wire transfers is often expensive. These companies make money by charging:

  • A percentage on the exchange rate, which is often invisible
  • High transfer fees to send or receive money

Image from Imgur

Even so, transparency is also a problem. According to ACORN Canada, out of 229 remittance users surveyed in Ontario, "27% of users had no idea whether exchange fees were included in the prices advertised by remittance providers." [1]

With the emergence of Bitcoin remittance providers in the past few years, they have started to disrupt the very industry that takes advantage of low-income individuals by charging high fees. But how does Bitcoin remittance work?

How Bitcoin Remittance Works

Image from Zach Copley

Let’s work with an example, with a sender who wants to transfer money from the US to India.

Step 1: Sender purchases Bitcoin with USD via one of the many exchanges available such as Coinbase (or LocalBitcoins).
Step 2: Sender sends Bitcoin to a Bitcoin remittance company.
Step 3: Bitcoin remittance company sends rupees to the receiver.

The entire back-end process for Bitcoin remittance is simpler than traditional remittances, where these 'legacy' companies involve clearing houses and banks.

But since Bitcoin’s value is known to fluctuate wildly, wouldn’t this affect the transmitted value?

While the Bitcoin’s value is indeed volatile, a sender will likely not be affected by this if the conversion from USD to BTC and BTC to INR (as in the example) happens in the same hour. [2]

To see whether a Bitcoin remittance provider is truly cheaper than traditional methods, let’s compare the costs of a few services.

Rebit.ph

Rebit.ph allows migrant workers and immigrants—their target market—to send money to the Philippines from countries such as Australia, Germany, Hong Kong, Malaysia, Singapore, the UK, and the US.

According to Luis Buenaventura, the co-founder and Head of Product at Rebit.ph, only about 10% of all Filipino adults have bank accounts.

Because of this, Rebit.ph pays out about 75% of migrant workers’ remittances through pawnshops, a feature not commonly found in other remittance services.

Comparison as of Apr 5, 2015:

Bitpesa:

Based in Kenya, Bitpesa is a Bitcoin-based remittance service that allows international money transfers to East Africa: namely countries like Kenya, Ghana, Tanzania, and Uganda. The company takes advantage of the popularity of mobile wallets in the countries, enabling them to convert Bitcoin to the supported local currency at low costs.

Comparison as of Apr 5, 2015 for transferring to Kenya:

Comparison as of Apr 5, 2015 for transferring to Tanzania:

While Bitpesa charges 3% on the BTC to KES / TZS exchange rate, Western Union still falls short by charging an even higher fee on the exchange rate, along with an additional transfer fee. You can read more about their fee structure and dissatisfaction of clients on this WU online payment review.

CoinPip:

This Singapore-based Bitcoin remittance company enables international money transfers to Singapore, Indonesia, and Hong Kong. They charge a 2% fee on the initial transfer amount, while the exchange rate used is the prevailing market rate without any fee imposed.

Comparison as of Apr 5, 2015 for transferring to Singapore:

Comparison as of Apr 5, 2015 for transferring to Indonesia:

Comparison as of Apr 5, 2015 for transferring to Hong Kong:

Even though CoinPip takes a 2% cut on the initial transfer, the final converted amount for the recipient is still higher than Western Union. The latter appears to charge a much higher percentage on the exchange rate.

Conclusion

Sending money using a Bitcoin-based platform is comparatively cheaper, as transmission fees in Bitcoin transactions are often very low.

We can see from the comparisons above that these Bitcoin remittance providers consistently charge lower fees than the regular mainstay, Western Union, while still managing to transfer the required currency in minutes up to a few hours. Western Union, on the other hand, can take several days depending on your payment method.

With 'legacy' remittance companies like Western Union, MoneyGram, and other traditional banks continuing to charge high fees while hiding other fees via poorer exchange rates, it’s hard to visualize a future where they’re still relevant. Startups that disrupt this predatory profiteering from migrant workers and immigrant workers are here now for social and economic justice—and with the recent trend, they're likely to stay.

The challenge here, therefore, is educating consumers on how using Bitcoin-based remittances can save them both money and time. And that's another story.

CoinGecko's Content Editorial Guidelines
CoinGecko’s content aims to demystify the crypto industry. While certain posts you see may be sponsored, we strive to uphold the highest standards of editorial quality and integrity, and do not publish any content that has not been vetted by our editors.
Learn more
Want to be the first to know about upcoming airdrops?
Subscribe to the CoinGecko Daily Newsletter!
Join 600,000+ crypto enthusiasts, traders, and degens in getting the latest crypto news, articles, videos, and reports by subscribing to our FREE newsletter.
Tell us how much you like this article!
Clement Chan
Clement Chan
Clement is currently working towards his CFP certification in New York. Read his insights on personal finance and travel on his blog. Follow the author on Twitter @saigoheiki

More Articles

Select Currency
Suggested Currencies
USD
US Dollar
IDR
Indonesian Rupiah
TWD
New Taiwan Dollar
EUR
Euro
KRW
South Korean Won
JPY
Japanese Yen
RUB
Russian Ruble
CNY
Chinese Yuan
Fiat Currencies
AED
United Arab Emirates Dirham
ARS
Argentine Peso
AUD
Australian Dollar
BDT
Bangladeshi Taka
BHD
Bahraini Dinar
BMD
Bermudian Dollar
BRL
Brazil Real
CAD
Canadian Dollar
CHF
Swiss Franc
CLP
Chilean Peso
CZK
Czech Koruna
DKK
Danish Krone
GBP
British Pound Sterling
GEL
Georgian Lari
HKD
Hong Kong Dollar
HUF
Hungarian Forint
ILS
Israeli New Shekel
INR
Indian Rupee
KWD
Kuwaiti Dinar
LKR
Sri Lankan Rupee
MMK
Burmese Kyat
MXN
Mexican Peso
MYR
Malaysian Ringgit
NGN
Nigerian Naira
NOK
Norwegian Krone
NZD
New Zealand Dollar
PHP
Philippine Peso
PKR
Pakistani Rupee
PLN
Polish Zloty
SAR
Saudi Riyal
SEK
Swedish Krona
SGD
Singapore Dollar
THB
Thai Baht
TRY
Turkish Lira
UAH
Ukrainian hryvnia
VEF
Venezuelan bolívar fuerte
VND
Vietnamese đồng
ZAR
South African Rand
XDR
IMF Special Drawing Rights
Cryptocurrencies
BTC
Bitcoin
ETH
Ether
LTC
Litecoin
BCH
Bitcoin Cash
BNB
Binance Coin
EOS
EOS
XRP
XRP
XLM
Lumens
LINK
Chainlink
DOT
Polkadot
YFI
Yearn.finance
Bitcoin Units
BITS
Bits
SATS
Satoshi
Commodities
XAG
Silver - Troy Ounce
XAU
Gold - Troy Ounce
Select Language
Popular Languages
EN
English
RU
Русский
DE
Deutsch
PL
język polski
ES
Español
VI
Tiếng việt
FR
Français
PT
Português
All Languages
AR
العربية
BG
български
CS
čeština
DA
dansk
EL
Ελληνικά
FI
suomen kieli
HE
עִבְרִית
HI
हिंदी
HR
hrvatski
HU
Magyar nyelv
ID
Bahasa Indonesia
IT
Italiano
JA
日本語
KO
한국어
LT
lietuvių kalba
NL
Nederlands
NO
norsk
RO
Limba română
SK
slovenský jazyk
SL
slovenski jezik
SV
Svenska
TH
ภาษาไทย
TR
Türkçe
UK
украї́нська мо́ва
ZH
简体中文
ZH-TW
繁體中文
Log in
By continuing, you agree to CoinGecko Terms of Service and acknowledge you’ve read our Privacy Policy
or
Forgot your password?
Didn't receive confirmation instructions?
Resend confirmation instructions
Sign up
By continuing, you agree to CoinGecko Terms of Service and acknowledge you’ve read our Privacy Policy
or
Password must contain at least 8 characters including 1 uppercase letter, 1 lowercase letter, 1 number, and 1 special character
Didn't receive confirmation instructions?
Resend confirmation instructions
Forgot your password?
You will receive an email with instructions on how to reset your password in a few minutes.
Resend confirmation instructions
You will receive an email with instructions for how to confirm your email address in a few minutes.
Get the CoinGecko app.
Scan this QR code to download the app now App QR Code Or check it out in the app stores
coingecko
Continue in app
Track prices in real-time
Open App
Join us at our first hybrid conference on 11 Nov 2024. Final chance to grab tickets at 25% off—don’t wait!